Your worst All-Time Blue?

joosforjihad · Post by **joosforjihad** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 6:51 pm

fargoblues wrote:
goon attack wrote:1st place: Dan Quinn
2nd place: Keith Tkachuk
3rd place: Adam Oates

honorable mention: Jack Quinn, Wayne Gretzky, Shayne Corson, Mike Keenan, Craig Janney, Ric Nattress, Dave Christian, Scott Pearson, Adam Creighton, Dale Hawerchuk, Petr Nedved, Jim Campbell, Darren Turcotte, the Goose, Chubby Turkey, Dave Barr
QFA

Chebaturkin! Yes! Hes got my vote.

northwest dave · Post by **northwest dave** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 6:58 pm

goon attack wrote:1st place: Dan Quinn
2nd place: Keith Tkachuk
3rd place: Adam Oates

honorable mention: Jack Quinn, Wayne Gretzky, Shayne Corson, Mike Keenan, Craig Janney, Ric Nattress, Dave Christian, Scott Pearson, Adam Creighton, Dale Hawerchuk, Petr Nedved, Jim Campbell, Darren Turcotte, the Goose, Chubby Turkey, Dave Barr

I'd figure Shayne Corson was your type of player.

glen a richter · Post by **glen a richter** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 7:05 pm

northwest dave wrote:
goon attack wrote:1st place: Dan Quinn
2nd place: Keith Tkachuk
3rd place: Adam Oates

honorable mention: Jack Quinn, Wayne Gretzky, Shayne Corson, Mike Keenan, Craig Janney, Ric Nattress, Dave Christian, Scott Pearson, Adam Creighton, Dale Hawerchuk, Petr Nedved, Jim Campbell, Darren Turcotte, the Goose, Chubby Turkey, Dave Barr
I'd figure Shayne Corson was your type of player.

Did Corson average 400 PIM's per season?

BF44 · Post by **BF44** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 8:34 pm

Phillippe Bozo(n)

theohall · Post by **theohall** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 9:21 pm

I'd have to go with

1) Harry Ornest - almost selling the Blues to Saskatoon after gutting a competitive team
2) Eric Brewer - by far one of the worst defenseman I've ever seen wear a Blues jersey. Still have no idea why he's a captain.
3) Mike Keenan - let's trade away all of the Blues talent for grinders..... and then wonder why they can't win playoff games.

not_a_wings_fan · Post by **not_a_wings_fan** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 9:41 pm

theohall wrote:I'd have to go with

1) Harry Ornest - almost selling the Blues to Saskatoon after gutting a competitive team
2) Eric Brewer - by far one of the worst defenseman I've ever seen wear a Blues jersey. Still have no idea why he's a captain.
3) Mike Keenan - let's trade away all of the Blues talent for grinders..... and then wonder why they can't win playoff games.

Speaking of loving grinders and not winning playoff games... have you seen what Murray's teams have done in the post season?

joosforjihad · Post by **joosforjihad** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 9:47 pm

not_a_wings_fan wrote:
Speaking of loving grinders and not winning playoff games... have you seen what Murray's teams have done in the post season?

If I remember correctly, they made it to the second round the season (2001) they traded Blake (their best dman) to Colorado. In that second round, they took the eventual champion Avalanche to a hard fought, competitive 6 games. In the next round, well I don't want to bring up that debacle.

not_a_wings_fan · Post by **not_a_wings_fan** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 9:51 pm

joosforjihad wrote:
not_a_wings_fan wrote:
Speaking of loving grinders and not winning playoff games... have you seen what Murray's teams have done in the post season?

If I remember correctly, they made it to the second round the season (2001) they traded Blake (their best dman) to Colorado. In that second round, they took the eventual champion Avalanche to a hard fought, competitive 6 games. In the next round, well I don't want to bring up that debacle.

That was the farthest he ever went. First round exits or don't make it other than that... and goals for went down each of the first three years he was in LA... just like we are doing here, lol.

He's a very good coach for college or minor league players, but he is NEVER going to win this or any team the stanley cup with his system.

joosforjihad · Post by **joosforjihad** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 9:57 pm

not_a_wings_fan wrote:but he is NEVER going to win this or any team the stanley cup with his system.

I'm not his biggest supporter or even saying that he shouldn't go if the struggles continue. BUT, if he does stay, I hope you have to eat those words!

Hallplante · Post by **Hallplante** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 10:12 pm

Amen.

How about trading for 18 of the 20 players on the roster [save for MacInnis and Hull], then claiming it is not "my team."

theohall wrote:Mike Keenan - let's trade away all of the Blues talent for grinders..... and then wonder why they can't win playoff games.

Winning Unlimited · Post by **Winning Unlimited** » Sun Nov 08, 2009 11:56 pm

Has anyone mentioned Jeff Finley yet? Too lazy to go back and read..

TSUCookieMonster · Post by **TSUCookieMonster** » Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:46 am

OPTIMEGUS wrote:Has anyone mentioned Jeff Finley yet? Too lazy to go back and read..

Yes, he was mentioned. I disagree though. By no means am I a Jeff Finley fan, but he did his job as a stay at home defenseman. The only problem I've gathered that people have with him was his complete lack of offensive capabilities. He wasn't a horrible defenseman, and CERTAINLY not the worst player to wear a Blues jersey, just a quiet player on the ice.

If you take away his last season as a Blue, ('03-'04) his stats weren't bad. Finished seasons +/-: +12, +26, +7, +12, -2

section319 · Post by **section319** » Mon Nov 09, 2009 3:52 pm

TSUCookieMonster wrote:
OPTIMEGUS wrote:Has anyone mentioned Jeff Finley yet? Too lazy to go back and read..
Yes, he was mentioned. I disagree though. By no means am I a Jeff Finley fan, but he did his job as a stay at home defenseman. The only problem I've gathered that people have with him was his complete lack of offensive capabilities. He wasn't a horrible defenseman, and CERTAINLY not the worst player to wear a Blues jersey, just a quiet player on the ice.

If you take away his last season as a Blue, ('03-'04) his stats weren't bad. Finished seasons +/-: +12, +26, +7, +12, -2

Brewer just wishes he could be close to -2.

northwest dave · Post by **northwest dave** » Mon Nov 09, 2009 6:13 pm

Charlie Huddy was pretty awful in a Blues uniform.

Hallplante · Post by **Hallplante** » Mon Nov 09, 2009 7:29 pm

Anyone remember defenseman Gerry Hart? Circa 1982.

All I can remember is him trying to freeze the puck in the corners on virtually all of his shifts.

section319 · Post by **section319** » Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:14 pm

Overall, Kariya hasn't been worth it at all, way too much money for what we have gotten out of him. I don't hate him by any means, but still worth mentioning.

philco_3 · Post by **philco_3** » Mon Nov 09, 2009 8:17 pm

section319 wrote:
TSUCookieMonster wrote:
OPTIMEGUS wrote:Has anyone mentioned Jeff Finley yet? Too lazy to go back and read..
Yes, he was mentioned. I disagree though. By no means am I a Jeff Finley fan, but he did his job as a stay at home defenseman. The only problem I've gathered that people have with him was his complete lack of offensive capabilities. He wasn't a horrible defenseman, and CERTAINLY not the worst player to wear a Blues jersey, just a quiet player on the ice.

If you take away his last season as a Blue, ('03-'04) his stats weren't bad. Finished seasons +/-: +12, +26, +7, +12, -2

Brewer just wishes he could be close to -2.

What -2 a night?

Leedog · Post by **Leedog** » Mon Nov 09, 2009 9:18 pm

The 3 Stooges, I mean Russians. Big V, little V, and Igor.
Craig Coxe was prolly the worst player to ever suit up in an NHL game, but he did look like Shaggy from Scooby Doo, so he keeps out of the cellar.

WaukeeBlues · Post by **WaukeeBlues** » Mon Nov 09, 2009 11:00 pm

Timofei Shishkanov

And just for re-iteration and for completely unrelated reasons,

Larry Pleau

YouTube · Post by **cprice12** » Tue Nov 10, 2009 1:21 pm

Rich Pilon
Adam Creighton
Vladimir Chebaturkin
Craig Coxe
Mike Eastwood
Dave Ellett
Denny Felsner
Dale Hawerchuk
Sean Hill
Jim Hrivnak
Charlie Huddy
Pat Jablonski
Yuri Khmylev
Igor Korolev
Patrick Lalime
Dean McAmmond
Joe Murphy
Vitali Prokhorov
Dan Quinn
Sergei Varlamov

Let's Go Blues

Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?

Re: Your worst All-Time Blue?